It's easy to say that the lawyer view is ridiculous, but (a) that is the view that defines the law, and (b) it seems far less ridiculous after one studies the history of copyright law beginning in the 1500s.įirst, the judge found Gorton, who is also LimeWire's sole director, personally liable for infringement, observing in her ruling that "an individual, including a corporate officer, who has the ability to supervise infringing activity and has a financial interest in that activity, or who personally participates in that activity is personally liable for infringement." The rights you have to your copy do not extend to all other instances of that file, even if they are indistinguishable or not. In the eyes of the law, however, those song files are NOT the same, because they have different histories. What this means is that if you and your friend each own a copy of the same album, you may feel it is reasonable to copy data from his disk when convenient, since you legally own a copy with the exact same contents. Two identical files with different histories are different entities. To a lawyer, the pedigree of a digital file just as important as the content. Two files with identical contents are indistinguishable and interchangeable. To an engineer, the content of a digital file is the primary attribute. There is a crucial difference between how lawyers and engineers view the issue: it just feels like more work to search for something so small in the browser, open it in a new app, clutter uTorrent with a thousand tiny downloads. I suppose it works as well for small files as large. It's fast, it's easy, you don't spew your hot, sticky IP all over the Gnutella network, you can use it from any smartphone with a web 's gotten extremely polluted with fake spam index-of sites, but there are also sites that helper filter the spam sites.īitTorrent just seems like a waste of energy for music.but I don't really know why. So you search, sort by size, download something with a sane name of the right size, and probably never play it in WMP, just to be safe.īut really? The "index of" Google search has largely replaced LimeWire for me anyway. But man, there are a lot of files with names like that. "underage porn sex girl with horse and dog"Įven if you WERE looking for filthy, illegal porn you'd have to be an idiot to download that. Strangely, every song ever recorded has a "rare live recording" that you probably shouldn't download.ĥ. "Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights.mp3 (rare live recording)" Sort by size and find something near 1MB-per-minuteĤ. "Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights.mp3 ~ 3kB" Pretend Example Search: kate bush wuthering heightsĭo not download files whose names are identical to your searchģ. Search results are always crowded with garbage, but the spam is so crude that you'd have to be a moron to download it: I've never gotten anything troublesome from LimeWire.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |